“There is no waste – only resources in the wrong place”

Dowmann is a start-up from Ireland that produces biochar. The team works with various biomass wastes and tries to separate them into their most valuable components. Our columnist Markus Sekulla spoke to the Technical Director Robert Dowdall. Dowmann participates in the Carbon Removal ClimAccelerator programme of the EIT Climate-KIC, which is supported by Munich Re and ERGO.

Hi Robert, would you please introduce yourself? Who are you, and what does Dowmann do?

I'm Robert Dowdall, the Technical Director of Dowmann. I handle the technical aspects involved in making everything function smoothly. As for Dowmann's activities, we produce biochar and carbon removal – but that is only part of the picture. We work with various waste biomass materials, striving to separate them into their most valuable components. Through our processes, we convert the biomass into biochar, bio-oil, and even useful bio-chemicals. Additionally, we generate a lot of renewable electricity, which is supplied to the grid for societal benefit.

How many people work for you, and where are they based?

We have three individuals working for Dowmann, including myself, on a full-time basis. Additionally, we have two remote workers who assist as needed. We maintain a very lean operational structure. Geographically, our team is dispersed. I am based in Carlow, while Paul Manning, our Commercial Director, operates from Dublin. Cathal Moroney, our Financial Director, is situated in Cork. This dispersed setup has worked well for us but also contributes to reducing our own carbon footprint in a small way.

Could you describe what Dowmann does in simple words?

Biomass is the plants you see growing around us. But when these plants are harvested or become waste, they're often just left to rot without any further use or benefit. This is a real shame because biomass contains lots of useful building blocks (like LEGO) that could be cleverly reused to make even cooler stuff that society needs. That’s what Dowmann does, we separate the biomass LEGO and organize the blocks to make them more accessible for other purposes. In our view, there is no such thing as waste, just resources in the wrong place. We try to make the most out of this waste by turning it into valuable materials or new products that can help rather than harm the environment. Especially in areas where there aren't many other options or where people are facing challenges like reducing carbon emissions or finding solutions to technical problems.

Is your solution a factory or a machine, where you put in biomass? And what you get out is biochar?

Exactly, and to answer your first question: Our solution is a factory. Waste biomass is brought to that factory, where we process it using our machinery. The biomass is broken down and then separated into several different products, each with its own specific use. Yes, one of these products is biochar, which is an incredibly stable form of carbon storage and can be used to help improve degraded soils or to decarbonize concrete as an additive. Another product is a renewable oil, which can be used in heavy industrial boilers as an alternative fuel. Currently, these boilers use coal, oil, and sometimes gas. In the future, we see opportunities to further refine the oil and extract bio-chemicals. We have made significant strides towards realizing this already through incredible research, development, and demonstration support from the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland.

Interestingly, each Dowmann factory can satisfy 100 percent of its energy needs and even export surplus energy to the local electricity grid. This is possible because we produce our synthesis gas and use it directly in an onsite combined heat and power system. This means each Dowmann factory comes with renewable energy built-in as standard and helps set us apart from other Carbon Dioxide Removal (CDR) companies. CDR can be quite energy-intensive depending on the approach. To have maximum impact, that energy also needs to come from renewable sources. The electricity grid is massively constrained and often overlooked. We see this as a significant bottleneck for scaling many CDR solutions into the future and why having our renewable energy built-in is a real advantage.

Can you describe the moment when you knew that your idea had to be the start of a company?

Entrepreneurship has always been in our blood. We've started several companies in the past, so this isn't our first venture. We already had a similar solution in 2017 that we knew would work, but there was no market at the time. That changed in 2019 when we came across Puro.earth, which had established a marketplace for selling carbon removal certificates. And the market developed rapidly. During the COVID period, we focused on research and development. Now we are developing our second-generation modular system, which will allow us to scale quickly and efficiently. We have always had the attitude of going our own way and making a positive contribution, both in the environmental or social sector.

Looking ahead, what's your most important milestone for 2024?

We have a couple of significant milestones lined up for 2024. The primary one is the operation of our second-generation system, which consists of one module of several components that will be combined for the larger commercial system. Once operational, it marks a crucial demonstration milestone, leading to both technical and commercial advancements. We have partnerships in place for various products, enabling industry trials that will inform our routes to market, expected to be completed and operational within the next three to six months.

The second milestone is to have our system audited and certified by a reputable auditor for carbon removal. This certification will allow us to sell our first certified ton of carbon removal. Following this, armed with solid figures, we will seek project finance for our large-scale facility. Once secured, the commissioning of the entire factory is estimated to take about six months.

The volume of carbon removal that we require worldwide is 10 Gigatons per year. Where do you think we are now? Are we on an exponential upward trajectory, or is progress too slow?

Progress could certainly be faster, as there's always room for improvement. Many essential mechanisms are just beginning to take shape. For instance, the US is investing in CDR (Carbon dioxide removal), while the EU is developing frameworks like the CRCF (Carbon Removal Certification Framework). These initiatives are laying the groundwork with regulations, standards, and monitoring protocols. Once these structures are in place, I anticipate an acceleration in progress. Additionally, many CDR providers are still in the development phase or securing funds for deployment. While there's been a surge in new companies, they have yet to fully enter the market. Hence, the global supply of CDR remains relatively low.

Websites like cdr.fyi offer insights into the volume of carbon removal purchases, which, so far, have been dominated by a handful of major players, especially Microsoft. We need more purchasers willing to wait for developers to catch up because physical deployment lags behind demand due to the complexities of building physical infrastructure.

One of my favorite questions for start-up founders like yourself is: When it comes to the climate crisis, do you think the glass is half full? Or is it half empty? Can we still make it as the human community, or are we in despair mode?

I don't believe we're in despair mode, but I'd say the glass is probably twice as big as it needs to be. Yes, we do need more carbon removal, but we also need to address our excessive energy consumption as a planet. There are significant energy efficiencies to be gained simply by being smarter about our usage. For instance, commercial buildings often leave lights on unnecessarily after hours, which is just one example of many small changes that can add up over time.

What would be other smart changes?

The key is that we make smarter decisions about the types of energy we use. Increasing the share of renewables on the grid is crucial, and this transition is already underway. While the glass may seem full now, we could probably live just as comfortably with a smaller glass. This would make it easier for CDR companies to fill the gap removing surplus emissions using excess electricity. Despite the current assumptions about abundant energy, there's vast potential for efficiency improvements, especially in transportation. Building better infrastructure for more efficient public transportation could significantly reduce energy consumption.

Human behavior can change faster than infrastructure can be delivered.

We have the technology and expertise to make these changes; what we need is the ambition and will to act. There are plenty of smart engineers and technical experts ready to tackle these challenges if provided with the right environment and incentives.

Thanks, Robert, for your time and the effort for our planet!